People often ask, “why did you open a costume store?”

For the love of costumes!

Our journey began as a “seasonal only pop-up store” in the fall of 2008, moving in and out of several locations over the course of four years. It wasn’t until we found the perfect location, (an old funeral home!), in the summer of 2012, that we took the plunge into an “open all year” retail costume store and made Cape Coral our permanent home.

The Red Headed Witches offer the largest selection of costumes and costume accessories in Cape Coral for all ages and in all sizes.

From your classic Halloween looks, to superheroes and villains, through the decades and more, we strive to keep up with the latest and most unique costume trends. We offer lines that you won’t find in a typical Halloween chain store. Shop the Red Headed Witches for professional, quality makeup by Mehron, Hollywood film quality FX Transfers by Tinsley Transfers, Real Metal Jewelry (a 100% made in the USA product line), cosplay wigs, and the #1 custom fit fangs in the industry by Dracula House.

We pride ourselves on superb customer service.

Everyone who enters our store is greeted with a genuinely happy-to-see-you smiling face. We are knowledgeable of all of our product lines and love helping customers piece together their costume and makeup ideas.

Planning a party or special event?

We’ve teamed up with Heroes & Villains Character Entertainment Company and can send live characters to your next event. Create lasting memories for your child’s next birthday, book characters such as Batman, SpiderMan and many more! For more information, visit Heroes and Villains Facebook page!

Special FX makeup artist available by appointment!

Award winning artist Don Shepherd specializes in Halloween and zombie gore makeup and prosthetics appliances, fantasy characters, airbrushing, face painting. Above are just a few of his creations!

No need to wait until Halloween to dress up! The Red Headed Witches continue to brew up special events for the Cape Coral area! Be sure to check out the events page for information on not only upcoming events but past events and photos too! Sign up for our mailing list and get notifications for our upcoming events.